A minor biography of a major figure in which, as in so much current popular history writing, the priority seems to be on making the subject accessible to a general, if not downright under-educated, readership.
Clements is so intent on this that he ends up translating Chinese words that really don’t need it, so the simple “Prince Dan of Yan” becomes the almost impossibly unwieldy “Red Prince of the Land of Swallows”, which will only infuriate any reader who’s already familiar with the subject. Similarly, such matters as Chinese Five Element theory, a crucial part of the political thought of the time, are merely mentioned in passing as “superstitions”, as are such matters as number mysticism, alchemy and the Taoist quest for immortality; in effect, those things which were of central interest to the Emperor and which, one would have thought, made him interesting to a modern reader, take second place to the portrayal of a bloodthirsty founder of a totalitarian regime.
That said, the history of the founding of the Qin Empire is handled competently enough, although the man responsible for the terracotta army probably deserves better.
Bookmark this post with: